Nursing Homes in New Carlisle, Indiana
New Carlisle has 2 Medicare-certified nursing homes with 155 beds. The city average CMS rating is 2.5 stars, which is below Indiana's state average of 3.1 stars. 0 facilities earn a B grade or better and are recommended for family consideration.
Compare 2 nursing homes · data
Worth Considering
0
Facilities graded A or B that meet our quality standards
City Average
-0.59 vs state
Total Beds
155
across 2 facilities
High Risk Facilities
0
0 under CMS review
0 with abuse citations
Nurse Availability
55 min
RN time per resident daily
Meets CMS recommendation
Well Staffed
0
exceed staffing threshold
0% of facilities
Zero Fines
passed all inspections
✓ Start your search here
Trend
0
improved vs last year
0 declined
Top Rated in New Carlisle
Hamilton Grove
Explore Nearby Cities
Hamilton Grove
★★★★★ · 48/100 · 85 beds
Miller's Merry Manor
★★★★★ · 36/100 · 70 beds
Showing 1–2 of 2 facilities
All 2 Nursing Homes in New Carlisle
A-ZWant to learn more about nursing home care in New Carlisle?
Fines · Deficiencies · Ownership Data · Quality Comparisons
About Nursing Home Care in New Carlisle
**THE VERDICT:** New Carlisle, IN is not a favorable market for nursing home care. The standout is **Hamilton Grove**, but even this facility has significant concerns. Overall, families will find that the options here are limited and concerning, with no facilities meeting even basic standards for care.
**WHO TO CONSIDER:** While there are no clear recommendations, you may want to visit **Hamilton Grove**. However, be mindful of its **Grade D** rating, which indicates serious quality issues. Unfortunately, **Miller's Merry Manor** is another option that you should be cautious about, as it has a **Grade F** rating and a history of poor performance. Given the lack of good options in New Carlisle, it's advisable to explore nursing homes in nearby cities like South Bend or Mishawaka, where you'll find better-rated facilities.
**WHO TO AVOID:** Definitely skip **Miller's Merry Manor** due to its **Grade F** rating, which reflects severe deficiencies in care. Similarly, avoid **Hamilton Grove**, which holds a **Grade D** rating and has notable issues with staffing and resident care. A practical tip when visiting any facility is to ask for their latest inspection report and tour the common areas—this will give you a clearer picture of the environment and care standards.
New Carlisle at a Glance
Good News
- • 1 community-run facility (non-profit)
Be Aware
- • City average is below state average—research carefully
What's Changing
- → 2 facilities stayed the same
- ★ Overall: New Carlisle is stable
Questions New Carlisle Families Should Ask
Based on what we found in local inspection data
How many RN hours per resident do you provide daily?
CMS recommends 0.75 hrs; New Carlisle avg is 0.91 hrs (55 min)
Have you received any fines in the past 3 years?
0 of 2 New Carlisle facilities have zero fines
What were your most recent inspection findings?
Ask for specifics—0 local facilities have serious deficiencies
What is your staff-to-resident ratio on weekends?
Weekend staffing often differs from weekday levels
Finding Quality Nursing Home Care in New Carlisle, Indiana
New Carlisle, Indiana's St. Joseph County seat, has 2 Medicare-certified nursing homes with approximately 155 beds. Families should research carefully—quality varies significantly from one facility to the next.
New Carlisle vs. Indiana: A Concerning Gap
New Carlisle nursing homes fall below the state average on key quality metrics. The city's average CMS rating of 2.50 stars trails Indiana's statewide average of 3.09 stars by nearly 0.6 stars—a significant gap that families should take seriously. The below-average performance is somewhat surprising for a major urban area, where competition and workforce availability typically drive higher quality.
Federal inspection data reveals 0 facilities classified as high-risk based on patterns of serious deficiencies, complaints, or CMS enforcement actions. Only 0 of 2 facilities earn a B grade or better, meaning families should be prepared to look beyond the closest option to find quality care.
Understanding Our Trust Score System
The Trust Score is a 0-100 rating calculated from CMS's official nursing home database. The score combines five data categories:
- Health Inspection Results — Recent deficiencies, their severity, and patterns over time
- Staffing Levels — RN hours, total nursing hours, and weekend staffing
- Quality Measures — Clinical outcomes like falls, pressure ulcers, and rehospitalizations
- Penalties — Fines, payment denials, and enforcement actions
- Complaints — Substantiated complaints and their severity
In New Carlisle, 0 facilities score a B grade or better, indicating they meet quality benchmarks across these categories. We recommend families prioritize these facilities and carefully research any facility rated C or below before visiting.
Staffing: Meeting Standards in New Carlisle
Staffing levels are among the most important predictors of nursing home quality. Research consistently shows that facilities with more nursing staff—especially registered nurses—have better outcomes for residents.
New Carlisle facilities average 0.91 RN hours per resident day, which meets the CMS-recommended threshold of 0.75 hours. The typical New Carlisle resident receives approximately 55 minutes of RN attention daily—compared to the 45 minutes experts recommend.
0 New Carlisle facilities exceed CMS staffing recommendations. Families prioritizing staffing should look for facilities with the "Top Staffing" badge and ask specifically about RN hours during facility visits.
Ownership: Mix of For-Profit and Non-Profit
New Carlisle has 1 non-profit nursing homes and 1 for-profit facility. 1 of 2 facility is chain-owned, with the remainder independently operated.
Research suggests non-profit facilities often have higher staffing levels and fewer deficiencies on average, though ownership type alone does not guarantee quality. Families should evaluate each facility individually using inspection data, staffing levels, and recent deficiency reports.
Nearby Alternatives Worth Considering
New Carlisle's below-average ratings mean families may benefit from expanding their search to nearby cities. The following Indiana cities offer multiple nursing home options:
- Indianapolis — 44 facilities
- Fort Wayne — 26 facilities
- Evansville — 17 facilities
- Muncie — 11 facilities
- South Bend — 10 facilities
- Terre Haute — 9 facilities
Frequently Asked Questions
How many nursing homes are in New Carlisle, Indiana?
New Carlisle has 2 Medicare-certified nursing homes with a total of 155 beds. The city average CMS rating is 2.5 stars, which is below Indiana's state average of 3.1 stars.
What are the best nursing homes in New Carlisle?
Based on our Trust Score analysis of CMS inspection data, the top-rated nursing homes in New Carlisle include:
- • Hamilton Grove — Grade D, 48/100 Trust Score
- • Miller's Merry Manor — Grade F, 36/100 Trust Score
These facilities have strong inspection records and staffing levels.
Which New Carlisle nursing homes should I avoid?
We flag 0 facilities in New Carlisle as high-risk based on patterns of serious deficiencies, substantial fines, or placement on CMS's Special Focus Facility list. These facilities are marked with warning indicators in our listings above.
We recommend avoiding facilities with: Grade D or F, recent "Immediate Jeopardy" citations (indicating serious harm or risk to residents), or those on CMS's Special Focus Facility list.
The Bottom Line on New Carlisle Nursing Homes
New Carlisle has below-average nursing home ratings. Research carefully and consider nearby cities. Focus your search on the 0 facilities graded A or B, particularly those with zero fines and strong staffing.