Worth Considering
4
Facilities graded B or better with zero fines
Best Nursing Homes in Evanston, Illinois
4 of 8 nursing homes in Evanston (50%) meet our strict criteria. The Illinois statewide average is 29%.
4 recommended · 2 caution · 2 avoid · data
City Average
4.3
★
+0.00 vs state
Total Beds
711
across 8 facilities
High Risk Facilities
2
2 Grade F
$191,369 in combined fines
Zero Fines
4
/8
passed all inspections
Nurse Availability
0 min
RN time per resident daily
Below CMS recommendation
Why These 4?
The nursing home market in Evanston, Illinois, is strong, with 50% of the 8 facilities recommended for care. Families should be aware of two facilities in the avoid tier, which collectively have $128,267 in fines, while the top-rated Mather Evanston offers an excellent option.
Exceptional (Grade A, Trust Score 90+)
- 1 MATHER EVANSTON, THE (93) — Mather Evanston stands out with an excellent Trust Score of 93/100 and a prestigious 5★ CMS rating. With zero fines and a strong community focus as a non-profit, it offers top-notch, personalized care in a cozy setting with just 37 beds.
- 2 WESTMINSTER PLACE (90) — Westminster Place excels with a Trust Score of 90/100 and a 5★ CMS rating, making it a top choice for quality care. As a non-profit, it is dedicated to serving the community, providing a welcoming environment within its 105 beds and maintaining a perfect record with no fines.
- 3 ALDEN ESTATES OF EVANSTON (90) — Alden Estates of Evanston boasts a Trust Score of 90/100 and a 5★ CMS rating, ensuring a high standard of care for its residents. With zero fines and 99 beds, it offers a comfortable and well-managed environment, making it a reliable option for nursing care.
Strong (Grade B+, Trust Score 80-89)
- 4 THREE CROWNS PARK (85) — Three Crowns Park offers a solid Trust Score of 85/100 and a commendable 5★ CMS rating. As a non-profit with a focus on community values, it provides a supportive atmosphere for its 34 residents, all while maintaining a record free of fines.
The other 4 Evanston facilities didn't qualify — 2 carry Grade D or F ratings and 4 have fines totaling $191K.
Recommended
Mather Evanston stands out with an excellent Trust Score of 93/100 and a prestigious 5★ CMS rating. With zero fines and a strong community focus as a non-profit, it offers top-notch, personalized care in a cozy setting with just 37 beds.
Westminster Place excels with a Trust Score of 90/100 and a 5★ CMS rating, making it a top choice for quality care. As a non-profit, it is dedicated to serving the community, providing a welcoming environment within its 105 beds and maintaining a perfect record with no fines.
Alden Estates of Evanston boasts a Trust Score of 90/100 and a 5★ CMS rating, ensuring a high standard of care for its residents. With zero fines and 99 beds, it offers a comfortable and well-managed environment, making it a reliable option for nursing care.
Three Crowns Park offers a solid Trust Score of 85/100 and a commendable 5★ CMS rating. As a non-profit with a focus on community values, it provides a supportive atmosphere for its 34 residents, all while maintaining a record free of fines.
Proceed with Caution
These facilities don't meet our recommendation criteria but may still be viable options.
Also Worth Considering
Staffing Comparison
Staffing levels are the strongest predictor of care quality
| Metric | Top Facility | Evanston Avg | CMS Minimum |
|---|---|---|---|
| RN Hours / Resident / Day | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.75 |
| CMS Star Rating | 5 stars | 4.3 stars | — |
| Deficiencies / Inspection | 0 | 0.0 | — |
Facilities to Avoid
These facilities have significant quality concerns.
What Disqualified the Other 4?
Our criteria: Trust Grade B or better (score 70+) AND zero fines in 3 years
- Grade F facilities
- 2 Grade F — critical inspection failures
- Facilities with fines
- 4 Have fines totaling $191,369
- Low-scoring facilities
- 1 Scored below B — Trust Scores under 70
- Caution group
- 2 Had good grades but fines disqualified them
Questions Evanston Families Should Ask
Based on what we found in local inspection data
-
1
"What is your current CMS star rating and Trust Score?"
Evanston's city average is 4.3 stars
-
2
"Have you received any fines in the past 3 years?"
4 of 8 Evanston facilities have fines
-
3
"How many RN hours per resident do you provide daily?"
CMS recommends 45 min; Evanston avg is 0 min
-
4
"What were your most recent inspection findings?"
Evanston facilities average 0.0 deficiencies per inspection
Explore Nearby Cities
Houston has strong options, but nearby cities add even more choices
Houston at a Glance
Good News
- 12 facilities meet our strict criteria—20% of the market
- 3 exceptional A-grade facilities with 5-star CMS ratings
- 24 facilities with zero fines in the past 3 years
Be Aware
- 30 facilities carry Grade F—nearly half the market
- $3.2M+ in total fines across 37 facilities
- Worst facility has $448,216 in fines alone
Key Numbers
- Average Trust Score: 48.6 (dragged down by 30 F-grades)
- 82% for-profit, 13% non-profit, 5% government
- 9.4 average deficiencies per facility
Frequently Asked Questions
How many nursing homes in Evanston, IL are recommended?
4 of 8 nursing homes in Evanston (50%) meet our strict criteria of excellent inspection results and a clean record with no fines.
What makes a nursing home in Evanston "recommended"?
A facility earns our recommendation when it achieves a Trust Grade of B or better (score of 70+) AND has zero fines in the past three years. This combination indicates consistent quality care and regulatory compliance.
How should I evaluate nursing homes in Evanston?
Look beyond star ratings. Check for recent fines, abuse citations, staffing levels (especially RN hours), and inspection deficiencies. Visit in person during different times of day to observe care quality firsthand.