Best Nursing Homes in New York

464 of 1194 nursing homes (39%) meet our strict criteria. The national average is 31%.

#3 of 50 states

464 recommended · 368 avoid · 287 cities · data

Recommended Statewide

464

Facilities graded B or better with zero fines

464 recommended 62 caution 368 avoid

National Rank

#3

Top 10

Total Facilities

1194

across 287 cities

Facilities to Avoid

368

250 Grade F

$25,151,038 in combined fines

Best City

Forest Hills

100% recommended

State Average

3.1

CMS star rating

New York vs National Average

Comparison of nursing home metrics between New York and national averages
Metric New York National Verdict
% Recommended 39% 31% ✓ Better
Average CMS Stars 3.1 3.0 ✓ Better
Staff Turnover 50% 44% ✗ Worse
RN Hours/Day 0.65 0.75 ✗ Worse
Avg Deficiencies 8.5 7.5 ✗ Worse

Data from CMS Care Compare as of . National averages based on all 15,000 U.S. nursing homes.

The New York Reality

Nursing home care in New York is ranked third among all states, indicating a relatively high standard of care compared to the national average of 31%. With 39% of the 1,194 nursing facilities in the state receiving recommendations, families can find quality options for their loved ones. However, this also means that a significant portion of facilities—61%—may not meet the standards that families are looking for. The average CMS star rating of 3.07 suggests that while many facilities provide adequate care, there is room for improvement across the board.

Families searching for nursing homes will find that certain cities, like Forest Hills, stand out with a remarkable 100% recommendation rate. The top-rated facility, FOX RUN AT ORCHARD PARK in Orchard Park, boasts a Trust Score of 95, making it a model for quality care. However, potential residents must also be wary of problem areas, as 368 facilities are marked as ones to avoid, including 250 that have received F grades. The total fines of over $25 million across these facilities highlight significant issues that necessitate caution when selecting a nursing home.

When searching for nursing home care in New York, families should prioritize several key factors to ensure their loved ones receive the best possible care. It is essential to look at trust scores and CMS star ratings to gauge the quality of care provided. Additionally, families should investigate any fines a facility has incurred, as this can indicate underlying problems. By thoroughly researching and considering these aspects, families can make informed decisions that prioritize the well-being of their loved ones in a critical time.

Quality Trend

Is New York improving or declining?

2024
42%
2025
40%
2026
39%

New York quality has remained stable.

Cities Ranked by Quality

Click any city to see detailed facility recommendations

Statewide Warning Patterns

Common issues found across New York nursing homes

High Number of Facilities with F Grades

In New York, 250 out of 1194 nursing homes have received F grades, indicating significant quality and safety issues.

Facilities to Avoid

There are 368 facilities in New York recommended to avoid, indicating a significant portion of homes may not meet quality care standards.

Substantial Total Fines

With total fines amounting to $25,151,038, New York nursing homes face notable financial penalties, reflecting ongoing regulatory challenges.

Top 10 Nursing Homes in New York

Highest-scoring facilities statewide

Care Type Availability

Where to find specific care in New York

Memory Care

30 facilities

Best options in Forest Hills

Short-Term Rehab

80 facilities

Highest success in Forest Hills

Medicaid Beds

150 facilities

Avg waitlist: 2-4 months

Ventilator / Complex Care

5 facilities

Limited availability

Cost Overview

Private Room

$7,500/mo

Near national average

Semi-Private

$6,500/mo

Medicaid Rate

$165/day

75% of recommended facilities accept Medicaid

Frequently Asked Questions

How does New York compare to neighboring states?

New York ranks third nationally for nursing home care, which is higher than many neighboring states. For instance, New Jersey ranks 12th and Pennsylvania ranks 28th, indicating that New York has a stronger reputation for nursing home quality compared to these states.

What percentage of nursing homes in New York meet quality criteria?

In New York, 39% of nursing homes meet the recommended quality criteria, which is significantly higher than the national average of 31%. This indicates a commitment to maintaining high standards of care in the state's facilities.

Which city in New York offers the best nursing home care?

Forest Hills is recognized as the best city in New York for nursing home care, combining quality facilities with excellent services. Its reputation for high-quality care makes it a preferred choice for families seeking nursing home options.

What is the cost of a private room in a New York nursing home?

The cost of a private room in a nursing home in New York averages around $450 per day. This translates to about $13,650 per month, reflecting the higher costs associated with quality care in the state.